Friday - Sunday 11am-4pm (We're open the day after Thanksgiving)

Enjoy lunch overlooking the beautiful Keuka Lake!

More than just your typical dining experience, the Bully Hill Restaurant features innovative cuisine with breathtaking view of Keuka Lake. Whether it’s seafood, pizza, smoked barbecue, freshly prepared salads, or seasonal specials, there is always something new and unique to try at the Bully Hill Restaurant. We promise you’ll leave happy, well fed, and excited to come back for seconds! 


Lunch Specials

Portabella Crab Cake
Maryland-style crab cake atop a grilled portabella mushroom cap, topped with pan-seared scallops; served with cucumber salad, mixed greens, and fries.

BBQ Sampler
House smoked pulled pork, beef brisket, and quarter chicken; served with slaw, and choice of mac salad, baked beans, or rosemary fries.

Octoberfest Sampler
Red Jacket apple cider sauerkraut, smoked pork loin, Polish kielbasa, and German potato salad, served with a freshly baked roll.

Brisket Reuben
House smoked brisket, Red Jacket apple cider sauerkraut, Swiss, and thousand island dressing on toasted rye.

Rehearsal Dinners

Come check out the well appointed reception hall at Bully Hill! The venue features a spacious timber frame outdoor deck and a warm, rustic indoor hall appointed with the original artwork of Bully Hill’s founder Walter S. Taylor. When you book with Bully Hill you get much more than a venue in the heart of the Finger Lakes, we’ll help you put together a world class menu for your event paired wonderfully with your favorite Bully Hill Wine.


In addition to our spacious outdoor patio and banquet room, the Bully Hill Restaurant also features a well appointed meeting facility, perfect for your next corporate luncheon or conference. Book for the day and enjoy a private facility for your meeting and a lunch prepared especially for your event by our chef’s at the Bully Hill Restaurant. We can even arrange a special wine tasting and estate tour for your group the day of your event!